Hey Beau,

The only things I could think of being possible conflicts are the “User Role Editor” or Woocommerce. Here is the list of what is installed.

https://www.dropbox.com/s/ue0do6jjl0brzcq/plugin.png

It appears to work for the first email login, then all others fail afterwards. Testing from Chrome, IE, Firefox.

Any ideas?
Thanks,
Daniel